The Accused: A 17th Century Tale of Fear and Hysteria
The 17th century was a time marked by religious upheaval, political strife, and a widespread fear of the unknown. One of the most chilling aspects of this era was the witch trials that swept across Europe and America, claiming the lives of many innocent people. Among these dark chapters in history, the story of the Bakewell Witches stands out, offering a glimpse into the paranoia and superstition that gripped communities and stood out as a case of social justice against two women who were used as political and criminal leverage.
The 17th century was a time marked by religious upheaval, political strife, and a widespread fear of the unknown. One of the most chilling aspects of this era was the witch trials that swept across Europe and America, claiming the lives of many innocent people. Among these dark chapters in history, the story of the Bakewell Witches offers a glimpse into the paranoia and superstition that gripped communities; a case of social injustice against two women who were used as political and criminal leverage.
The Context of the 17th Century Witch Hunts
Before diving into the specifics of the Bakewell Witches, let’s explore the broader context of the witch hunts. The fear of witchcraft was not a new phenomenon; it had been simmering for centuries. However, the 17th century saw a dramatic increase in the number of trials and executions. Fuelled by a combination of factors: the Reformation, which heightened religious tensions; the aftermath of the Thirty Years’ War, which left societies fragmented and vulnerable; and the publication of influential texts like the ‘Malleus Maleficarum’ which provided a ‘guide’ to identifying and prosecuting witches.
Thousands of people, mainly women, were accused, arrested, tried and executed as witch hunts exploded across the country, spreading across Europe and America.
The Tale of Mrs Stafford and Her Companion
Bakewell, a picturesque market town in Derbyshire, England became an unexpected focus of witchcraft accusations early in the 17th century. The story centres on Mrs Stafford and her companion, who were accused of witchcraft.
In 1606, Mrs Stafford, a local milliner and her younger female companion found themselves at the centre of a community’s fears. In this tragic case, the most sensational claim against them was the accusation that they had used their witchcraft to teleport a man who was lodging with them, to London - a feat that, even by the standards of witchcraft accusations, was extraordinary and outrageous. The man, whose identity remains obscure in historical records, claimed that he had been magically transported over 140 miles from Bakewell to the capital in the blink of an eye. This accusation of teleportation from two local women would have been compelling and proof of the women doing the work of Satan.
But the accusations against Mrs Stafford and her companion did not stop at teleportation.
The fear and suspicion quickly snowballed, leading to their arrest. As in the case of many women accused of witchcraft, there would likely have been additional accusers, other women and their families who lived and worked in the town. Perhaps fearing that they be also accused, or compensating for wrongs they felt had been done against them by Mrs Stafford in the past; the neighbours and townsfolk may have offered little to support their innocence for fear of retribution from the authorities. Here, centuries old ideas of herbal healing, the power of nature, keeping talismans for luck or weaving simple rings to symbolise the circle of life were no longer deemed innocent.
The Trial and Aftermath
The trial of Mrs Stafford and her female companion took place in Derby Gaol, in front of a crowd of eager spectators. The court proceedings would have seen a mix of genuine belief in witchcraft, retribution and a desire for a form of justice. The accusation provided an alibi for the lodger who was caught in a cellar in London, five days after he was in Bakewell, with a bundle of silken clothes, presumably stolen. This was also an opportunity for a judge to be applauded for sentencing two women involved in an extreme act of sorcery. Witnesses may have come forward with accounts of Mrs Stafford’s supposed supernatural abilities and the harm they believed she had caused.
Despite the fantastical nature of the teleportation claim, the prevailing atmosphere of fear and superstition would be enough to sway the court’s judgment. Both women were found guilty of witchcraft.
The case of Mrs Stafford and her companion highlights the extreme lengths to which fear and hysteria could drive a community. It also underscores the role of sensationalism in the witch trials; the more bizarre and dramatic the accusation, the more likely it was to be believed.
Reflecting on the Bakewell Witches
The story of the Bakewell Witches serves as a powerful reminder of the dangers of fear and ignorance. It underscores the importance of critical thinking and the courage to stand up against injustice. While it is easy to look back on the witch trials with disbelief, it is crucial to recognise the parallels in contemporary society where fear and superstition can still lead to persecution.
As we share the story of the Bakewell Witches let’s mark their memory with action. Let’s strive to build communities based on empathy, understanding, and rationality. By learning from the past, we can work towards a future so such tragedies are not repeated.
Share Your Thoughts!
What are your thoughts on the Bakewell Witches and the broader context of the 17th-century witch hunts? How do you think fear and superstition manifest in today’s society? Share your comments and join the conversation!
Don’t forget to like, share, and follow for more intriguing historical tales and insights! You can also download the Chronicles of The Bakewell Witches GeoStory, a reimagining of the women’s story, straight to your mobile – experience the story in Bakewell, the place where history happened; or from anywhere.
Please take a moment to explore our website and share with friends, colleagues and networks. We really appreciate your continued support, thank you! GeoStories.co.uk
References:
1. Levack, Brian P. *The Witch-Hunt in Early Modern Europe*. Routledge, 2016.
2. Sharpe, James. *Instruments of Darkness: Witchcraft in Early Modern England*. University of Pennsylvania Press, 1997.
3. Gaskill, Malcolm. *Witchfinders: A Seventeenth-Century English Tragedy*. Harvard University Press, 2005.